Doubt and the Monastic Journey

By Monk Kilian

Within the Tradition of our Church, monastic tonsure is considered a sacrament, a holy mystery, and thus forms for the monk or nun a liminal event in life. Many sources consider tonsure to the schema a “second Baptism,” and having been recently tonsured myself as a stavrophore monk, I can vouch for the aptness of this description. Tonsure is the beginning of another life: all sins are washed away, the old man is laid aside, and a new person is born with a new name, given by the abbot or abbess and taken by the newly-enrolled soldier of Christ in love and obedience. Like any mystery in the Church, tonsure itself and life as a fully professed monk is hard to put into words; I must admit I was a bit daunted by the task of speaking of doubt and tonsure simply because it defies expression on many levels. As with baptism or marriage, you cannot fully know what to expect on the other side of the font or the next day after the wedding. At these thresholds of our life in the Church, we have to leap out in faith, trusting that God is leading us along His path.

I had been a monastic for five years before my tonsure, and when I first entered the monastery, I was chomping at the bit to be tonsured into the schema. I had no clue about the hard work, both physical and spiritual, that monastic life would lay on me in order to peel away at least some of the passionate crust around my heart in order to begin to see who I really was, and who God wanted me to be. Yet this process, as necessary as it may be, is also very frightening. Over the past few years, I’ve had to confront my own weaknesses in a very matter-of-fact way. I’ve had to humble myself (or be humbled, as it were) and deny myself: my way of thinking, my desires for my life, my understandings of where life was going. In preparing for crossing the threshold of monastic tonsure, I was faced with a huge battle centering on belief and doubt. To the reader, it will hardly sound surprising that the evil one is far from thrilled to hear that a man or woman wishes to profess monastic vows. If we imagine the whole body of the Church as an army of the faithful here on earth regarding the spiritual life, monks and nuns are like the elite special-ops teams. We stand on the front lines of the battle for the world, and the enemy sends the fiercest attacks against us. This onslaught I too had to face in the weeks before my tonsure.

The candidate prostrates himself before the Metropolitan

So many thoughts and questions barraged me, even thoughts against the basis of my faith, which hadn’t happened in a long time. Does God really exist? How do you know He answers your prayers? Don’t you want to have sex and a family? Will you really be satisfied as a monk? You’re such a sinner, how could you even dare to think you’re worthy of the schema? Why don’t you just do what you like doing? You’re good at academics, why throw a career away?

Not pleasant at all, that swarm of thoughts. The Fathers teach us simply to disregard these suggestions (in Greek, logismoi), saying that the second we start listening to them, we start becoming entangled in the snare, and the harder it is to escape. For myself, I’ll simply say that after weeks of this kind of attack, I was at the bottom of the barrel spiritually speaking. I was faced with a seemingly huge choice.

On the one hand, I had monastic vows before me. This meant a life of ascesis, of constant struggle to overcome my passions by God’s grace, of being rejected and scorned by the world, and often misunderstood even within the bosom of the Church. It meant being alone (this is the monos part in monastikos) and not having an exclusive partner to walk along life’s path with me. On the other hand, I had a life pleasing to the world and one leading away from life within the Church. This was a life that was easy, one according to my passions, one that could give me success and approval by many in society.

Finally, after much prayer and some wintry solitude in the cold north of Alaska (another story for another blog entry, perhaps), God filled me with such clarity regarding monastic life, and I hastened with joy to petition for vows, which my spiritual father accepted gladly. But while the doubts about tonsure in general had been conquered, doubts about that life in a specific way still lingered. What will my life be like after tonsure? What name will I be given? Seeing as I’m currently a student, I thought of how this might impact my relationships and affairs with classmates and the administration.

The Candidate is presented to the Metropolitan for Monastic Tonsure

The day of my tonsure arrived, and even then, inclement weather forced the bishop to be delayed and the tonsure was moved to the next day. Many people came to me with sympathy, but I was laughing. God in His humor was showing me how utterly lacking in control I was, and how utterly provident and omnipotent He was. Tonsure would take place on His schedule and to His glory.

It’s been nearly a month now since my vows, and life is so beautiful, so pregnant with meaning in ways I cannot put into words. As one of my brother monastics said to me, you can speak much of the life of a professed monk, but you’ll never know it until you take that leap of faith into that life of obedience. I think now that I needed to experience this doubt so that I could then turn not to worldly wisdom, but faith, and make that leap into the Father’s embrace in my vows.

4 thoughts on “Doubt and the Monastic Journey

  1. Juliana

    While I cannot even begin to claim the level of spiritual struggle a monastic faces, I do feel a connection with the question of doubt and logismoi as a newly wed. It’s amazing how this new life, albeit extremely different than the monastic life, still places before me challenges to my faith, temptations toward my passions, and yet at the same time, opportunities to grow in love and humility. It becomes clearer each day how the fathers of the Church could say that the monastic life and the married life, while different, are both blessed states in which to work out our salvation. I think that God works through both in order to challenge us just enough in order to make us place all our reliance on Him alone, and realize that we are not in control, and that He alone is the source of all of our blessings. Thank you for such an inspiring post!

  2. Zosimas

    Your post echoes what Elder Paisios the Athonite writes in his EPISTLES, in the section directed to those preparing for the monastic vocation. As a layman doing precisely that, yet still in the world for a (hopefully) short time, I can vouch for the flood of thoughts, the temptations, the pleadings of family, the circumstances, the allure of a life in the world (and perhaps even outside of the Church), all holding out the temptation of being able to serve God in an active way (while still indulging the passions, the ego). It is one thing to read about these challenges from a contemporary saint, or even to have one’s spiritual father speak about them, but it is quite another to hear it from one who is in the very process, who can share, as you have done, how one has persevered all the way to the sacred tonsure. Thanks be to God for this encouraging post!

  3. Karen

    Many years, Father! And may the Lord make them all fruitful for Him. It was a joy to read your post.

  4. Christopher

    How can I tell you of the pain in my heart as I suffer the buffetings to my soul, the war of thoughts and my failings?

    Brother Kilian, you have spoken what is in my heart as I approach monasticism and wonder if it is I who withdraws or God’s will. Knowing myself: self-willed, critical, intolerant, unforgiving, arrogant, rational, with not a shred of humility and love, I blame myself for all that has come about. God forgive me. Yet somehow, for me, nothing else makes sense, I still yearn for monasticism.

    As I search for the beneficial in my failings so far and how your experience informs us, perhaps the process and the pain in this approach to monasticism, even if it results in initial failure, is part of the stripping away of all that is “i am” in place of “He who IS!”. Perhaps, having tasted the bitterness in my soul and offered up to His healing the depth even my secret and unknown sin, I will be able to approach, in God’s time, place and conditions that community in which I can finally become a monk without destroying myself or my brothers.

    I thank you for the sign posts and experience along this road.

    Forgive me and pray for me even though I am worthless, conscious of my reliance on Christ, having only two things left, a feeble faith and hope. May God help me and may He grant us the greatest blessing of being together before Him in eternity.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>